id summary reporter owner description type status priority milestone component version resolution keywords cc 9309 Preset Enhancements jphilipz team "I'm a new user to JOSM and do love the F3 key as it does save alot of time, but i would like to suggest some improvement to presets. == Enchanced Search == One possibility is that the dialog's main drop down menu values are also taken into consideration of the search (ex. 'Place of Worship' -> building type values, except for value 'yes'). Another possibility is to have an internal keywords field for each preset that has common keywords for each preset (ex. 'Place of Worship' -> keywords = church, mosque, temple | 'Convenience Store' -> keywords = grocery). I make this suggestion as when i started off using JOSM as a new user to OSM, not familiar with OSM's classification of things, i made mistakes on the map like placing supermarket entries instead of convenience store entries as i wasnt able to find grocery store in the preset. By doing this i believe that the learning curve can be improved for new users to OSM/JOSM and an enhanced search will benefit everyone. == Preset Default == It would be nice to be able to possibly have a checkbox or button in the preset dialog to set the dialog's default values to appear when the dialog appears (similar to how the 'Man Made/Man Made/Building' auto sets 'yes'). I say this as I am in the country where 98% of places of worship are mosques, and it would be nice to be able press F3, select 'Places of Worship' and just press enter. == Drop Down Menu Relationships == It would be an enhancement to have relationships between drop down menu values, so that when one drop down value is set, other drop down menus are filtered from irrelavant entries (ex. if i select 'church' as building type in Place of Worship dialog, 'muslim' doesnt appear under religion and 'shia' and 'sunni' dont appear under denomination). This will also assist in people not putting in incorrect values. == More Presets == If the 'Preset Default' option mentioned above is added, this suggestion wouldnt be as crucial, but still would come in handy as you could only have one default preset per dialog. I believe a moderate amount of commonly used presets can easily be gathered from seeing more commonly used tags at taginfo.openstreetmap.org or simply asking JOSM users to submit and vote for new ones. I personally would like to have presets for Facilities/Culture/Place of Worship/Mosque, Highways/Waypoints/Traffic Calming/Bump, Highways/Waypoints/Traffic Calming/Hump, Highways/Ways/Dedicated Footway/Bridge. Of course everyone's needs for additional presents will be different and I wouldnt want to burden the JOSM team to come up with all the possibilities, so maybe all users to have a user defined preset text file which then can modify, and formatted something like this. -------------- Facilities/Culture/Place of Worship/Mosque amentity = place_of_worship building = mosque religion = muslim Highways/Waypoints/Traffic Calming/Hump* traffic_calming = bump --------------- The entries in the file would have to be defined as subentries of existent presets, so that the same dialog can be fired up. The second entry had a '*' at the end of the preset name which would tell the dialog not to appear (alternatively a 'prompt = no' can be used instead of this). Alternative to this, maybe an internal preset editor can be created." enhancement closed normal 14.01 Internal preset fixed