id Summary Status Owner Type Priority Milestone 3841 Validator: show meaningful tooltips new team enhancement major 6102 Non-Connected way checks in validator needs to be projection independent new defect major 15182 Standalone JOSM validator new team enhancement major Longterm 21796 No JOSM warning for a way that technically is not overlapping, but it is. new team defect major 3495 Automatic way combining new team enhancement normal 3496 Background checking mode for validator new team enhancement normal 4626 parallelize validator checks new team enhancement normal 5203 Key to jump to next error new team enhancement normal 5641 Painting error layer is very slow new team defect normal 6189 Duplicate nodes in two un-closed ways new team enhancement normal 7397 UX improvements for click handling on validator bugs new team enhancement normal 7788 validator should accept some kinds of way overlaps new team enhancement normal 8399 Validator could merge two ways with same position if one is an inner without tags new team enhancement normal 8460 Validator checks for Public Traffic Proposal relations new team enhancement normal 8622 Junction validator? new team enhancement normal 9125 shop=ice_cream should be detected and fixed to amenity=ice_cream reopened team enhancement normal 9297 detect nodes with unneeded railway=level_crossing new team enhancement normal 9299 detect nodes with unneeded railway=crossing new team enhancement normal 9376 "For building=roof without layer tag, intersecting with roads, footways, cycleways etc validator should mention that typical roof is above other objects and it should have ""layer=1"" tag" new team enhancement normal 9400 validate source:maxspeed new team enhancement normal 9513 Fix self-intersecting ways new team enhancement normal 9534 "Strange ""overlapping water areas"" test result" new team defect normal 9652 case of names new team enhancement normal 9679 [Incomplete Patch] Validator complains about key: *:lanes:conditional (etc.) reopened team defect normal 9819 [PATCH] stricter checking for highways crossing waterways without bridges needinfo reichg defect normal 9895 checking correct use of noexit new team enhancement normal 10003 Convert access=hov to access=no + hov=yes [PATCH] new team enhancement normal 10122 Atempt to list nameless ways in validation results menu new team enhancement normal 10167 Attempt to sort route roles in relation new team enhancement normal 10178 "bogus ""Superfluous turnrestriction as ""to"" way is oneway (1)""" new team defect normal 10226 Verify multiple equal values new team enhancement normal 10263 better validation of roundabouts new team enhancement normal 10324 test whether relation member ways are properly ordered new team enhancement normal 10551 Tag that imply linear object and tag that imply area object should not be used on element without explicit area=yes/no reopened team enhancement normal 10875 Flag waterway/road crossing with missing tunnel/bridge attr new team enhancement normal 10982 Validate turn restrictions with to = from new team enhancement normal 10983 Check double housenumbers new team enhancement normal 11101 Issue a warning when multipolygon relations grow too large new team enhancement normal 11153 [WIP PATCH] improve readability of validator warnings new team enhancement normal 11175 "[Patch] ""Ways with same position"" gives errors that are not" needinfo Sylves defect normal 11348 "Crossing way check works only for ""on demand"" but not for ""on upload""" new team defect normal 11451 Allow references to inner object matches with ∈ (element of) operator new team enhancement normal 11455 Allow explicit fix target selection with ∈ (element of) operator new team enhancement normal 11692 "Better test for ""Crossing boundaries""" new team defect normal 11970 Possible problem when comparing key with a replace() value new team defect normal 11982 duplicated nodes which is not used in way or relation reopened team enhancement normal 11983 """Crossing ways"" operator in MapCSS" new team enhancement normal 12310 "Validator: add ""gap between buildings""" new team enhancement normal 12334 Validate some more unneeded turn restrictions cases new team enhancement normal 12772 Make it possible to temporarily select some validator tests before running it new team enhancement normal 12786 using the validator autofix when tags were changed after the validation process results in an incorrect autofix new team defect normal 12841 Support splitted roundabouts in roundabout validation test new team enhancement normal 13146 UnsupportedOperationException: Unable to remove primitives from TestError new team defect normal 13472 Detect areas mapped on top of highway=* areas new team enhancement normal 13517 Warn users if hw=path is a lone tag new team enhancement normal 13600 too far away check does not use multipolygons new team defect normal 13651 conditional tag: False warning with complex opening_hours values in combination with AND new team defect normal 13971 "Explain what ""fix"" ""autofix"" button will do for every check using captions" new team enhancement normal 13992 URL validator on source:url new team defect normal 14092 Should not suggest to downgrade the classification of some roundabouts new team enhancement normal 14096 Optional use of subgroups triggered by number of hits new team enhancement normal 14290 Parent selector is selecting both child and parent new team defect normal 14378 Global territory selector new team enhancement normal 14479 Validation Rule Level: Level sollten nur Zahlen mit optionalen 0,5 Schritten aufweisen: bitte entfernen new team enhancement normal 14532 "check for invalid ""layer"" tagging on tunnel=* and bridge=*" new team enhancement normal 14944 "Validator - Include Warning About Simultaneous Use Of ""Classic"" And ""New"" Contact Tagging Scheme" new team enhancement normal 15136 Ignore validator warning for no_u_turn where from and to new team enhancement normal 15155 Group opening_hours warnings by object or opening_hours tag value. new team enhancement normal 15366 override standard rules with custom validator rules to remove some tests new team enhancement normal 15640 Check for possible unneeded only_* restrictions new team enhancement normal 15726 Not returning the value when using tag() new team enhancement normal 15752 Test for landuse inside landuse new team enhancement normal 16190 add validator warning for fire_hydrant:type=pond new team enhancement normal 16262 [PATCH] Add BuildingOutsideResidentialArea test. assigned marxin enhancement normal 16280 autofix for almost square check for buildings is suboptimal new marxin defect normal 16283 [PATCH] Add new validation test for broken circle buildings. new team enhancement normal 16395 Warning/test for possible wrong lanes count reopened team enhancement normal 16803 [Patch needs rework] Validator: Wrong warning Highway link is not linked to adequate highway/link reopened team defect normal 16917 Give zoom-to the first on right click of validator groups and subgroups new team enhancement normal 16918 Autoexpand validator report classes (Error, Warning, Other) new team enhancement normal 17011 Multiple warnings for same problem new team enhancement normal 17074 detect railway=level_crossing nodes that are not on crossing of railway=* and highway=* ways new team enhancement normal 17172 [WIP PATCH] turn:lanes and lanes should match new team enhancement normal 17243 Add checked validator keys/tags to Taginfo? new team enhancement normal 17271 Cannot add assertMatch/assertNoMatch declarations with set declarations new team defect normal 17295 [WIP Patch] All categories are folded by default new team enhancement normal 17340 JOSM should check relations for ways with no nodes (e.g., partially deleted ways) new team defect normal 17390 provide autofix for removal of unneded boundary=administrative tags new team enhancement normal 17403 Complain about crossing administrative boundary with road and stop offering to join administrative boundary and road due to duplicated nodes new team enhancement normal 17406 Complain about nodes shared by man_made=pipeline and highway=*, do not offer to merge nodes of man_made=pipeline and highway=* new team enhancement normal 17422 Improve zoom to problem with crossing ways new team enhancement normal 17425 MapCSS assert, support test with context new team enhancement normal 17472 Warn about redundant cycleway tags new team enhancement normal 17488 complain about cycleway=opposite_lane, cycleway=opposite without oneway=yes new team enhancement normal 17511 Incorrect validation warning: turn restriction for oneway=yes with oneway:bicycle=no new team defect normal 17533 Check waterway flow direction reopened team enhancement normal 17609 Detect invalid usage of ZWNJ/ZWJ characters new team enhancement normal 17653 """Duplicate housenumber"" warnings on interpolations" new team defect normal 17751 error with custom mapcss using regex reopened team enhancement normal 17770 deprecate service=irrigation/transportation/water_power? new team enhancement normal 17822 Change source:geometry -> source:position MapCSS rule new team enhancement normal 17846 Complain about an unreasonably small buildings for types indicating bigger buildings new team enhancement normal 17874 Propose to change landuse=reservoir to natural=water+water=reservoir new team enhancement normal 17955 Wrong multipolygon validation when filter is applied new team defect normal 17998 check for correct value of access new team enhancement normal 18014 Validator marks no_entry and no_exit-restrictions as an error new team enhancement normal 18031 Complain about natural=rock used for large areas and suggest natural=bare_rock instead new team enhancement normal 18042 complain where wikipedia tag is used instead of correct brand:wikipedia (or wikidata instead of brand:wikidata) new team enhancement normal 18065 "Add fix for ""Ways with same position"" warning in Validator" new team enhancement normal 18074 Small issue with precision new team enhancement normal 18240 Force/propose/automatically download of incomplete multipolygon relations for validation new team enhancement normal 18364 [WIP PATCH] Find routing islands new team enhancement normal 18415 interpret things like change:lanes=no as 0 lanes for the validator new team enhancement normal 18488 Lane count validation new team enhancement normal 18579 Warn when adding a url with /commons.wikimedia/ to image= new team enhancement normal 18604 Validator doesn't give warning when a natural=scrub and natural=wood areas overlap new team defect normal 18610 Do not show warning about modified incomplete multipolygon when only tags were added/modified new team enhancement normal 18763 Way terminates on Area is - sometimes - a False Positive? Slipway? Entrance? new team enhancement normal 18813 Recategorize error, warning and info level and subgroup them new team enhancement normal 18831 Switch to ConditionalRestrictionParser new team enhancement normal 18854 Validation for stream and river direction new team enhancement normal 18892 Features missing in OpeningHoursParser compared to JS library new team enhancement normal 18893 [Patch] OpeningHourTest highlight erroneous part in string assigned simon04 enhancement normal 18989 Some more warnings for direction and railway new team enhancement normal 19008 Differences in results outside downloaded area between no download area at all and small download area somewhere new team defect normal 19093 "Warn about ""destination"" with ""turn:lanes""" new team enhancement normal 19095 "Warning about ""*:lanes=*"" tagging without ""oneway=yes""" new team enhancement normal 19096 "Warning about incorrect role ""forward/backward""" new team enhancement normal 19203 Don't warn about nodes with note=* tag only new team enhancement normal 19306 Complain about free-floating building:part new team enhancement normal 19462 Complain about addr:housename matching addr:housenumber and differing solely by capitalization new team enhancement normal 19511 Support of complete tag in fixChange and FixRemove new team enhancement normal 19519 property value for multiselect always produce false positive with multiple values new team defect normal 19534 Find gaps in incomplete route relations with some members downloaded new team enhancement normal 19546 Warn about overlapping building:parts new team enhancement normal 19600 flag highway that terminates on amenity=parking new team enhancement normal 19616 Better handling of zero-width space (\u200b) in URL new team enhancement normal 19649 Specify key name in Number of lanes greater than *:lanes new team enhancement normal 19652 abandoned:building disused:building - convert to building new team enhancement normal 19653 Find more conflicting keys in lanes-tagging new team enhancement normal 19665 Warn about building with name but missing primary tag. new team enhancement normal 19677 [Patch] Unnecessary tagging: cycleway:surface + surface + highway=cycleway new team enhancement normal 19722 Turn restriction validator warning inconsistency new team defect normal 19748 Risky autofix: Incorrect roundabout (highway: primary instead of {trunk/motorway}) new team defect normal 19863 "vadilation: false positive, * without railway" new team enhancement normal 19956 [WIP Patch] Double check if error still exists before executing autofix reopened GerdP defect normal 19961 Validator should flag a warnings for unnecessary boundary tags on unclosed member ways new team enhancement normal 19977 Create new validator for aeroway=runway new team enhancement normal 20029 missing tag - turn:lanes:forward without lanes - although lanes:forward and lanes:backward are correct new team defect normal 20054 Overlapping areas: Allow areas inside areas sharing segments new team enhancement normal 20055 Ignore file for session new team enhancement normal 20057 Improve handling of preference `validator.UnconnectedWays.way_way_distance` assigned GerdP enhancement normal 20071 Validator Preferences: Reset java tests to default settings missing new team enhancement normal 20081 Does not find unconnected, new waterways outside downloaded area new team defect normal 20103 Warn about short ways new team enhancement normal 20130 [Patch] Use mapcss rules instead of CrossingWays java code to find overlapping areas assigned GerdP enhancement normal 20236 Add some validator rules (psv:lanes / lanes:psv etc..) access vs lane count information new team enhancement normal 20254 "Ignore list: Misleading entry ""Presets do not contain property key""" new team enhancement normal 20300 problem with Crossing railways validation new team enhancement normal 20306 """Water area inside water area"" triggered for reedbeed in a lake" new team defect normal 20316 Opening_hours: Does not like `PH +1 day PH` new team defect normal 20334 "Validator - complain if tag is present with different ""lifecycle"" states" new team enhancement normal 20384 Flag changed way segments going outside of the download area new team enhancement normal 20441 Remove pointless duplicates of motor_vehicle=no new team enhancement normal 20451 Warn about supermassive avoidable multipolygons (landuse=farmland for start) new team enhancement normal 20473 Multipolygon repeating the tag of an outer way is not flagged new team defect normal 20485 Inconsistent handling of fixme tags new team defect normal 20498 fixChangeKey is proposing autofix when data may be erased new team enhancement normal 20559 "Improve text ""House number without street""" new team enhancement normal 20663 [patch] Area style on outer way not flagged when different river area taggings are combined assigned GerdP defect normal 20664 False positive finding on wall areas mapped as multipolygons new team defect normal 20713 Suppress validator warning for amenity within amenity for school new team enhancement normal 20718 Remove deprecation warnings for is_in tag in the DRC new team task normal 20760 Private phone numbers and proprietary sources reopened team enhancement normal 20832 [patch] Unknown turn restriction for restriction:hgv:conditional=no_left_turn new GerdP defect normal 20864 Orphaned building parts needinfo JsfasdF252 enhancement normal 20909 """No area style for multipolygon"" produces lots of duplicates" new team defect normal 20916 The SimilarNamedWays test reports false positive on Arabic street names new team defect normal 20931 Warn about leading and trailing white spaces in role values and offer a fix new team enhancement normal 21129 Warn about missing primary key for all known relations new team enhancement normal 21163 [WIP Patch] Validating an object (way with conditionals) fails new team defect normal 21249 Warn about conflicting or unneeded values in access tags new team enhancement normal 21286 [Patch] Add validate rule min_height < height reopened team enhancement normal 23.05 21332 Role verification: Always list parent relation in addition to members new team enhancement normal 21341 Access restriction node without object new team enhancement normal 21351 Gratuitious warning on turn restrictions new team enhancement normal 21399 Check for valid secondary tags of power plant and generator new team enhancement normal 21433 Wrong warning of the URL validator new team defect normal 21461 Complain about water=river (or waterway=riverbank) with names new team enhancement normal 21525 Boundaries for specific areas inside a country for validation rules new team enhancement normal 21542 Problem with Ignore list and new objects new team enhancement normal 21632 Wrong syntax in hazmat:conditional key new team defect normal 21636 Validator should give warning for leisure=horse_riding without name new team enhancement normal 21707 validator test for post_office:type=* new team enhancement normal 21711 Allow tourism=attraction inside tourism=attraction new team defect normal 21712 Report overlap between building=* and highway=pedestrian areas new team enhancement normal 21722 [patch] Warn about turning_circle with barrier new team enhancement normal 21741 Unicode 'Modifier Letter Colon' (U+A789) gives spurious warning new team defect normal 21755 Add highway=speed_camera validator new team enhancement normal 21777 [patch] Tag combination: foot=no + sidewalk=left/right/both new team enhancement normal 21832 Complain about disused:shop with opening_hours new team enhancement normal 21870 "Opening hours: Possibly false positive ""can be prettified"" with complex value" new team defect normal 21887 amenity inside amenity should always consider layer tag new team defect normal 21908 "False positive ""street name contains ss/ß"" with route relations" new team defect normal 21915 Validator: Similarly named ways (dealing with road names with '/' in them) new team enhancement normal 21930 [PATCH] Support new conditional parking lane tagging in validator new team defect normal 21949 Adding a validation rule for key:bus:lanes:forward shouldn't have numeric value new team enhancement normal 22023 Warn on mixed use of sidewalk:both=* and sidewalk=* new team enhancement normal 22147 "For waterway start node avoid ""Way end node near other way"" warning" new team enhancement normal 22168 Add 'man_made=quay' to ferry route connection check new team defect normal 22200 Validation only: power transformer/compensator compatibility with substation new team enhancement normal 22218 Warn when highway=living_street is combined with bicycle_road=yes assigned GerdP enhancement normal 22284 Warn about indoor=no inside and indoor=yes outside of a building polygon new team enhancement normal 22328 "[Patch] Nodes should be exclude from ""construction:highway without highway and construction""" new team defect normal 22329 "Many false positives for "":lanes"" tagging with additional prefix" new team defect normal 22343 Warn about junction=roundabout with oneway=no new team enhancement normal 22412 Complain about end_date in the past new team enhancement normal 22437 suspicious tag combination tracktype=grade2 and surface=ground new team defect normal 22467 building:part with the same position as the building gives a false warning new team defect normal 22495 Warning when using a relation restriction:bicycle=give_way needinfo anonymous defect normal 22512 [Validator] nodes with lwn_name=* and no name should be valid new team enhancement normal 22544 Adding a check for wrong wikimedia_commons syntax new team enhancement normal 22545 natural=valley and =fell can be used on nodes new team enhancement normal 22579 JOSM should not warn about unconnected way ends, if these are certain POIs new team enhancement normal 22611 Validator - add a test for traffic_signals=* - less specific or undocumented values new team enhancement normal 22619 Validator should not warn for direction relations which use roundabout new team defect normal 22639 "False validator warning ""voltage:* without transformer""" new team defect normal 22668 Complain about disused:shop=yes shop=florist and similar combinations new team enhancement normal 22731 """Unkown value"" does not properly handle white space" new team defect normal 22758 Dedicated, error level complaint about combining highway=* and building=* on one way new team enhancement normal 22781 Warning for highway and layer combination new team enhancement normal 22816 Check for check_date:xxxx if tag xxxx is updated (and offer to fix it) new team enhancement normal 22820 duplicate way : sometime with(out) auto-repair new team defect normal 22872 Incorrect 'overlapping water ways' validation warning new team defect normal 22909 The tag waterway=water_point is no longer deprecated (since 2015) new team task normal 22915 Allow semi-colon list in frequency=* new team enhancement normal 22925 Disable check for incorrect roundabout direction for roundabout=turbo new team defect normal 22928 Warn about bicycle=use_sidepath with conflicting cycleway tags new team enhancement normal 22940 [Patch] add autofix for node[type=multipolygon] and most way[type=multipolygon] new team enhancement normal 22985 "mapcss ""area"" rule: inconsistency asserts and validator" new team defect normal 23054 """Segregated"" on railway=tram_crossing" new team defect normal 23126 area:highway should probably count here as highway new team enhancement normal 23147 Add validation for missing pylons in aerialway ways new team enhancement normal 23193 False positive warning on source:*:conditional new team defect normal 23199 Using placeholders and selector classes breaks validator new team defect normal 23206 Placeholders in mapcss expressions don't work in suggestAlternative new team defect normal 23338 Nameless highway areas reported as error new team defect normal 23344 After correcting errors flagged by pre-upload validation, restarting upload does not clear the highlights new team defect normal 23358 Better warning for bridge on suspicious object reopened team enhancement normal 23375 Mapcss: allow retrieving current year new team enhancement normal 23385 leisure=bathing_place on a way raises a warning, but wiki says otherwise new team defect normal 23463 unnecessary.mapcss suggests removing area=yes from railway=platform for indoor features new team defect normal 23571 Meaningless informational messages for contact: prefix new team defect normal 23585 "Allow ""Ignore for now"" on multiple validation items" new team enhancement normal 23601 Warn about incorrectly connected highway with man_made=bridge or man_made=tunnel and different layer values new team enhancement normal 23615 Incorrect warning: crossing barrier/way, for fence entering water new team defect normal 23620 man_made=clarifier being corrected to =clarifer new team defect normal 23695 JOSM warns about usage=spillway on water=canal areas even though that seems to be the accepted pattern new team defect normal 23750 "Exclude addr:* tags from the ""Presets do not contain property values"" validity check." new team enhancement normal 23794 False positive for power line? new team defect normal 23829 validator not recognizing highway=pedestrian on multipolygon areas as part of the highway grid new team defect normal 23852 Warn about width=0 new team enhancement normal 23865 Problem with the regions validator (false positive) if there are duplicate presets (like one for inside the US and Canada and one for outside the US and Canada) new team enhancement normal 23912 Hide validator after upload reopened team enhancement normal 23935 Add addr:streetnumber for same function like addr:housenumber in Addresses.java needinfo afhafkartograf task normal 23936 """unusual value of direction"" validator should include ""inbound"" and ""outbound""" new team defect normal 23938 """key""=value crash the validator" new team defect normal 23941 bicycle:conditional=dismount results in a validation error new team defect normal 23966 MapCSS validator: Turn:lanes:forward and change:lanes:forward with oneway=* tag is marked as a suspicious combination new team defect normal 23974 Suspicious combination: False positives for way[incline] new team enhancement normal 23996 Convert non-standard dashes to standard dashes in the Opening Hours field new team enhancement normal 24001 sport=chess and amenity=table combination wrongly detected as missing a physical feature new team defect normal 24033 [Patch] There should be a validator warning for the deprecated key building:roof new team enhancement normal 24053 Validator: Detect invalid barrier nodes needinfo anonymous enhancement normal 24114 Validate location:transition=yes as incompatible with line_management=termination new team enhancement normal 24144 Incomplete pedestrian crossing tagging. Required tags are highway=crossing|traffic_signals and crossing=*. (4) - appearing on cycleway with foot=no new team defect normal 24148 "Validator warns about ""overlapping buildings"" when a building overlaps a building:part" new team defect normal 24216 [PATCH] Validator shouldn't raise warning about missing tag for informal crossing new team defect normal 24280 [PATCH] Validator: allow more than one from for no_entry restriction new team enhancement normal 24337 Validator: add AT:city_limit* and AT:shared_zone* to source:maxspeed new team enhancement normal 24367 Zoom to problem sometimes not helpful new team enhancement normal 24387 "Using railway=station creates validation warnings with ""crossing railways""" new team defect normal 24407 Warnings about Unicode characters of triangle symbols in inscriptions of highway=milestone are unnecessary and confusing (at least in Germany) new team defect normal 24418 Placeholders and tag() don't work in group key for validator MapCSS expressions new team defect normal 24457 Power line_section relations presets and validation new team enhancement normal 24476 [PATCH] Validate tree diameter and height new team enhancement normal 24546 parking=yes deprecated for amenity/tourism/office new team defect normal 24555 validator rejects parking:fee:conditional=no @ stay < 90 minutes new team defect normal 24603 """shop=windows"" should not be listed as a deprecated tag" new team defect normal 24647 cycleway=asl not on cycleway - incorrect validator warning new team defect normal 9924 same geom and all tag of one way are include in the second new team enhancement minor 11374 Wrong validator assert does not give a hint about the line new team defect minor 12493 [PATCH] Categorize 'Way end node near other highway' warnings. new team enhancement minor 12918 Warn about 1,2,3,4,5 year old shops/amenities new team enhancement minor 13444 A Validator Warning should be produced when Parking Access Tag Keys not correct new team enhancement minor 17129 Cannot add assertMatch/assertNoMatch declarations with :selected pseudoclass new team defect minor 18375 warn on waterway and highway shared node that is not a ford new team enhancement minor 19575 Missing translation test needs tweaks new team defect minor 20078 Unconnected ways and areas special cases new team enhancement minor 20248 Warn of stiles on bridleway (or path with designated bicycle/horse) new team enhancement minor 20569 False positive finding on wash trails new team defect minor 21242 Create autofix for sidewalk=none -> no new team enhancement minor 21778 Validation error: oneway + oneway:conditional + bicycle:backwards:conditional reopened team defect minor 21979 Validator for crossing highway/waterway doesn't activate if the highway isn't edited. needinfo SherbetS defect minor 22013 [Patch]Validator should accept denomination=sufi instead of denomination=sufism new team defect minor 22105 Wrong informational message: Incomplete pedestrian crossing tagging new team defect minor 22388 Warn about cycle-route tags used on ways with bicycle=no/use_sidepath new team enhancement minor 22714 disabled:conditional=designated @ (Mo-Fr 09:00-20:00;Sa 09:00-18:00) not valid? new team defect minor 23644 validator suggests suspicious replacement new team defect minor 24078 [Patch] Warn when addr:*=* is added to a relation new team enhancement minor 24494 Erroneous warning about crossing highway/railway when using railway=yard on an area new team defect minor 14155 Warning: amenity=place_of_worship inside amenity=place_of_worship new team defect trivial 20214 "data/validation/tests/ConditionalKeys.java:RESTRICTION_TYPES should include ""smoothness""" new team enhancement trivial 20381 Validation text crushes ValidateUploadHook dialog. Help button missing. new team enhancement trivial